Song Beneath the Song: “American Pie” by Don McLean

“AMERICAN PIE,” Don McLean’s magnum opus that spent four weeks at #1 in 1972, is a “dirge in the dark,” a song about the ramifications of the plane crash that claimed the life of Buddy Holly. Over the course of six verses, seven choruses, eight-and-a-half minutes, and any number of cryptic allusions approaching the Biblical in both scope and obscurity, the narrator inveighs against the British Invasion. The point is this: American music—viz., good music—died with Charles Harden Holley.

“The Day the Music Died” refers to 3 February, 1959 (“February made me shiver”), when Buddy Holly perished in a plane crash (“the plane climbed high into the night”), along with Ritchie Valens and The Big Bopper (neither worthy of mention in the song). When the chorus of “good ol’ boys” lament that “this’ll be the day that I die,” they are coyly alluding to Holly’s hit “That’ll Be The Day:”

You say you’re gonna leave
I know it’s a lie,
Cuz that’ll be the day-ay-ay
That I die.

Since the release of “American Pie”  in November, 1971—just 12 years after the death of American music—listeners have played the roman à clef game, attempting to divine, often with the aid of mind-altering substances, just who the allegorical characters in the song are supposed to represent. Is “The King” Elvis, as is commonly assumed? Is “The Jester” Bob Dylan? The “girl who sang the blues” Janis Joplin? And who are the enigmatic “three men I admire most / the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost” who board the last train to California in the final verse? This tantalizing ambiguity is part of the song’s charm.

Whatever the meaning of the individual references, the chronological flow of the song seems clear. We begin at a dance in a high school gym, presumably early in ’59, as “The Book of Love” plays—the age of pink-carnation innocence, before the Lubbock sound was corrupted by Liverpudlians—and jump to ten years later (1969, a decade after Holly’s demise), where the malefic influence of the Beatles (“the Sergeants played a marching tune,” “Lenin/Lennon read a book on Marx”), the Rolling Stones (“moss grows flat on a rolling stone,” “Jack Flash sat on a candlestick”), the Byrds (“the birds/Byrds flew off from the fallout shelter, eight miles high and falling fast”), and, curiously, the Grateful Dead (“fire is the devil’s only friend”) have adulterated the purity of American rock ‘n’ roll. We check off all the Baby Boom cultural milestones: the Manson murders (“helter skelter”), Woodstock (“and there we were in one place, a generation lost in space”), and Altamont (“no angel born in hell could break that Satan’s spell”), as well as the film Rebel Without a Cause (“a coat he borrowed from James Dean”).

In spite of all this generational excitement going on around him, however, the narrator (b. 1945) is unmoved. Nothing—not the Beatles, not the “girl who sang the blues,” not even the Summer of Fucking Love—can make him forget the loss of Holly, whose memory he invokes with a reverence akin to religious zeal. If the three men he admires most (Hendrix, Morrison, and Clapton? Sinatra, Martin, and Sammy Davis Jr.? Nixon, Agnew, and Kissinger? Does McLean even know?) are the Father, Son, and the Holy Ghost, Holly, we might assume, is a trinity all to himself. Once you get past the reverence, the whole endeavor seems kind of silly.

Look, no one disputes the genius of Buddy Holly. Even the Beatles worshiped at his altar; the name of their band is meant to echo Holly’s own outfit, the Crickets. Just 23 when he died, Holly nevertheless left behind enough material to fill a solid greatest hits album. It could be argued—indeed, “American Pie” itself makes the argument—that his loss at such a young age is the single worst tragedy to befall the popular culture in the twentieth century. His untimely death deprived us of who knows how much great music. Or, to put it in Holly’s own words, “All my love, all my kissin’, you don’t know what you been missin’.  Oh, boy.”

Nevertheless, I can’t help but find this song reactionary, a musical equivalent of MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN. I saw McLean perform when I was in high school—it was my first concert, in fact, back in ‘87—at the gym at Drew University (so he saw us dancing in the gym). I loved “American Pie” and “Superman’s Ghost” and “Vincent” and “Castles in the Air,” so I was excited for the show. McLean was not. At one point, he tore into Paul Simon, finger-picking a thirteenth chord and mockingly singing “At the Zoo.” It was uncomfortable, because his bitterness was so obvious. Basically, he came off like a jaded old man who hates anything new—you know, like the narrator of “American Pie.” That the cover of the album—McLean flashing the thumbs-up, with the American flag imprinted on his thumb—looks like a Tea Party political ad only underscores this conservatism.

Buddy’s gone, Don. Take a sad song and make it better.

About Greg Olear

Greg Olear (@gregolear) is a founding editor of The Weeklings and the author of the novels Totally Killer and Fathermucker, an L.A. Times bestseller.
This entry was posted in Song Beneath the Song and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Song Beneath the Song: “American Pie” by Don McLean

  1. Lewis Clark says:

    Spot on.

    Also, I believe there’s a certain class of popular song which, for some reason many people seem to wanna have a crack at, yet, to preserve the sanity of bartenders, waitresses and other innocent bystanders, should *never* be allowed to be performed as Karaoke. Certainly “American Pie” would be #1 on that list.

  2. Interesting song, with great lyrics, thanks for sharing your thoughts.

  3. Rickggd says:

    Amid the pandemic, dating app usage has shot up by double digits, based on Morning Consult trend data. You might know somebody or be dating somebody who’s in the beginning stages of alcoholism. You may be ready to get to know the children however the single guardian has rather more at stake after they invite you into their family. In case you have significant issues in this area, say about their approach to discipline, autonomy, or household dynamics, the partnership won’t be one of the best match for either of you-particularly in case you hope to have kids of your own sooner or later. Grabbing a last-minute romantic lunch or jet-setting to your dream vacation spot on a moment’s notice will not be attainable for a single mother or father, significantly if they are parenting totally on their very own, have no household close by, or don’t have reliable childcare. Your accomplice is the skilled father or mother, and they’re probably not concerned about having you step in and critique their parenting type or discipline ways, significantly early on in a relationship. If you can’t respect their judgment and consolation level on how a lot time to spend with the kids and what sorts of intimacy are Ok of their presence, this relationship will not be best for you.

    For example, it would assist to make it a point to share little reminders of how a lot you every worth your relationship in the hectic mixture of your on a regular basis lives. Want help with homework? This should be a no-brainer, however you’d be stunned how many individuals (women and men alike) assume they’re going to get over it in time, solely to rediscover later that they never needed to dwell with or help increase someone else’s children. Alcohol simply means more to them than it does to other people. For more psychological health resources, see our Nationwide Helpline Database. A very actual, basic hazard is to kids’ and teens’ psychological well being. Recordings can be shared as UGC testimonials after every occasion. Successive collisions between accreted our bodies led to the formation of larger and bigger planetesimals, lastly forming the Earth-Moon system in a giant impact event. In-person dates could also be off the desk for the time being, but that hasn’t stopped people from swiping by means of their dating apps whereas they’re on lockdown. Most of these apps are owned by the same firm (Match Group, a subsidiary of IAC).

    The emotional well-being of the youngsters, as well as facilitating an optimum relationship between you and the youngsters, are pressing issues that the guardian needs to weigh. If you’re aggressive with the youngsters, you are setting your relationship up for failure. Childcare, including the schedule [url=]qpid[/url] and needs of the kids, will all the time be a high priority. If it is time to say goodbye, do so lovingly, with out dragging it out or assuming things will change. While both of you could possibly change your mind down the road, there is no assure that you will. We ignore the indicators that he can’t “ship” and as an alternative decide we can change his mind if we simply hang on. But there can be some inform-tale early indicators that somebody is likely to be an alcoholic. Listed below are a number of indicators that dating a single dad or mum may not be a good fit for you proper now. It can be arduous to know upfront whether dating a single guardian is right for you, but you may save quite a lot of heartbreak if you are trustworthy with your self and potential partners from the beginning. Particularly early on, it is best to anticipate biting your tongue so much. When you are dating a single father or mother, it’s splendid to respect their timing in the case of introducing you to the children and taking your relationship to the next stage of merging your families.

    Self-awareness is every thing in relation to healthy relationships. Typically, it’s necessary to attend to be requested before sharing your opinion on parenting points. Whereas there aren’t many dating issues which are black-and-white, this is one in every of them. This particular person won’t go to a little bit League sport, but will definitely go to a school sport the place there will likely be tailgating. Who was your favorite superhero while you have been little? There are many alternatives and it’s additionally your duty to locate your favorite spot. It is vital to respect that there are some ways to guardian-and that your partner is the mother or father of the little one. If you are uncertain concerning the baby component, personal as much as it from the beginning and keep away from investing your time and your heart in a relationship that can fail. The bottom line is to acknowledge how you are feeling about having kids (and these particular kids) in your life (in the current and future) and make decisions about your relationship with these feelings in mind. Your feelings aren’t right or incorrect.

  4. Joedll says:

    Even if it’s been 5 days or a week, just hold your horses. Don’t hold something again. You possibly can look again on it a month later and see areas for enchancment. Your three piece go well with or physique con costume isn’t going to look as beautiful when you’re sidelined. Have a look at occurring dates, even if they don’t work out, as apply. They’re probably not different apps: they work the same, and even have the same interface. If it’s clear you haven’t put any thought or effort into your profile, potential partners might assume you will take the same strategy in a relationship. In line with the survey, 60 % of ladies ages 18 to 34 say someone on an app or dating site stored contacting them after they stated they weren’t fascinated whereas about the identical share of girls in that age group reported that they were despatched unsolicited sexually express pictures or messages. When you is likely to be anxious it is not a good idea (or perhaps a waste of time), like all issues in love, it has its execs and cons.

    In an effort to help daters really feel and act assured whereas avoiding becoming a subject for Dangerous Online Dates, the location helps each women and men project the image they want and walk out the door feeling safe in their individuality. If you utilize the ideas outlined above it’ll provide help to. The ultimate piece of recommendation right here is to accept that you will encounter rejection. The ultimate thing I wish to say is that online dating will be onerous if you don’t get outcomes right away. This tip may seem like a no-brainer, but scammers can be artistic and convincing as they try to steal your id. Hat tip to Nathan Yau [url=][/url] at Flowing Data, who launched us to the information on how couples meet. This will assist the software program to seek out the correct folks for you and also find people who are in search of you. Keep it to the fundamentals and only share generic data that gives others a fundamental thought of who you’re. The fantastic thÑ–ng аbоut online dаtÑ–ng Ñ•Ñ–tеѕ is that thеу’ll act оn whаt you tеll thеm your preferences are. Althоugh mоѕt реорlе will ѕау lооkÑ• dоn’t mаttеr, thеу nonetheless wаnt tо ѕее whаt thе оthеr particular person looks lÑ–kе ѕо at all times роѕt a Ñ€hоtо with уоur profile аnd роѕt a сurrеnt оnе.

    You will learn so many things in other ways. You will have to complete a brief form to entry it for the primary time solely. Select a espresso shop or restaurant close to your private home in order that you set in minimal effort to go on this first meetup. In case you don’t put the minimal effort in to create an online dating profile, it exhibits you’re not taking it significantly and doesn’t bode well for the sort of effort and attention you would possibly put right into a date or a relationship. So let’s put the fears to relaxation-and put the internet to the take a look at. However, the web is a spacious playground and supplies an unlimited community of internet sites and companies to carry like-minded individuals nearer together. We know assembly folks on the internet can have its advantages, you just should be cautious. A healthy relationship is completely possible whether or not you’re assembly folks in individual or on-line, but the 2 strategies differ for a wide range of reasons. If things should not working out, read our relationship advice. Here are loads of suggestions that you simply might discover useful in touchdown a date online.

    This is likely to be a sign of curiosity. Bobby. An excessive amount of wit and charm could provide you with butterflies, however it may also be a sign that the particular person is a “player” or perhaps a narcissist. Be sure you understand tips on how to cancel your membership before you sign up. Often placing up conversations is about developing the mindset of in search of opportunities to make a connection wherever you go, Chlipala explains. In acknowledging that your online dating profile represents the particular person that you are, you’ll be able to then focus on creating your pursuits, communication and social abilities. Too many people soar into online dating sites with no concept of what to jot down down within the profile or choice part, after which get pissed off once they don’t find the best person. It’s simple to get disheartened after a number of weeks of using courting apps with no nice results. If you have ever heard stories from your folks about their bad dates, you may moderately strategy courting apps with warning. Slavic ladies love assured men, however a lot obsession may trigger suspicions. We also can teach you how you can turn into more assured with women in the actual world.

  5. Liukel says:

    In contrast to actual life relationships, you’ll be able to all the time say cease to an internet toxic relationship. Traditionally, Ukrainian women cease working as a cam girl when they’ve a boyfriend or husband. Due to this case, you need to browse ladies who just started to work as a cam girl. To browse without cookies, you can configure your browser to reject all cookies, or to notify you when a cookie is ready. The music is a rootsy mix of sailor’s songs, Mexican and Balkan tunes, rock, and hip-hop, and the steamy night ends with a set from Turkish-Gypsy outfit Something About Reptiles. There is a wide variety of personalities. Consequently, there are a lot of psychos on cam lady websites. However, Ukrainian psychos do work as cam girl for a few years and no men need thus far them. Some girls didn’t need to talk. Costs differ from platform to platform, however most males dating Ukrainian women online spend about $1200 a yr. Below you’ll be able to study the names and forms of the months, the kinds of numbers we use for the dates, in addition to how you can say the yr in Ukrainian. Supporters and partners cannot be held accountable for any use that may be made of the knowledge contained therein.

    Don’t use your private electronic mail handle, create a disposable e-mail tackle for this goal. I chose beneath an inventory of cam girl websites the place you’ll be able to at some alternate your email deal with with an Ukrainian lady. This website lets you exchange personal particulars like an e mail address with her. When you enter the chat room of such a woman, you uncover they don’t appear to be in the pictures. I (Alain from Montreal, Canada) feel like the luckiest man on the planet. Once you`ve contacted single Ukrainian women, developed a relationship and each really feel that the time has come to fulfill in individual, our experienced marriage agency workers will help you and offer you the providers required so you’ll be able to meet your beautiful Ukrainian bride in her hometown! Нigh-high quality companies provide you with a chance to construct romantic relationships together with your dream lady. They know the way to build a profession of their own. There’s an applicable value fee per minute in each circumstances.

    The value for them begins at $3.99 for 2 credits. When arriving in Ukraine, just look round and you’ll notice that almost all of the girls there wear sneakers with high heels which help draw attention to their unbelievable legs. There are nice women on-line too. That’s why it may be value making a black record with the nicknames of those toxic women. You will rapidly see if a girl is value talking to or not. You have to be choosy if you’d like to meet a pleasant Ukrainian lady online. I don’t need to lie to you. Don’t fall in love with a toxic lady. Give yourself the chance to fall in love and have a possibility of marrying Ukrainian girl. Communication is certainly important, and in relationships, you’ll give sure promises. You need to do this to get essentially the most out of the communication and save your money and time.

    So, it may possibly provide help to save cash if you read the description of the webcam model first. Evaluate the lady in a textual content chat first. That’s why I recommend not to activate your webcam in a first chat session. If the first option seems dangerous and dear for you, check out online courting as lovely Ukrainian women on related sites often have severe intentions and are ready for lengthy-term dedication. It is not any marvel that they proved to be the most effective possibility for those seeking a woman of goals abroad. I do encourage you to leave a personal chat as quick as doable when you find that the lady at the opposite end shouldn’t be respectful. It could take some occasions earlier than you find one. But, before you accomplish that, please take the time to verify if the cam model is trustful. Be curious. Don’t stick to at least one category of cam women [url=]ukraine babes[/url].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *