Like a Heart Floating in Formaldehyde: A Letter to the President-Elect

The Weeklings participated in a nationwide Writers Resist event on January 15, at Bearsville Theater in Woodstock, NY. Over thirty readers and musicians participated, and more than $6,000 was raised for endangered causes Planned Parenthood, The New York Civil Liberties Union, and Riverkeeper. This letter was one of the pieces that was read that day. 

 

TO THE PRESIDENT-ELECT,

The first time I met you was in a dream I had in the 1970s. You appeared as The Greediest Man in the World. Some sort of really sinister archetype. You told my hardworking mother and father they were losers, then tried to take all their money to buy a new yacht. You were, quite possibly, the Child Catcher from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, which is to say, the scariest figure in my psyche. Marauder of innocence and hope. You grabbed my Barbie dolls and tore their heads and legs off. Luckily, I woke up and it had all been a bad dream, and I was safe.

In the 1980s I vaguely knew you actually existed. I was reading a lot of books, a lot of poetry. And you—you were the opposite of poetry. No rhythm or grace and nothing to say. You were the world of dollar signs and commerce, you were the clanking machinery of jobs and bills and cogs in wheels, and I thought I could outrun you.

The 1990s, well, there we were, both in New York. You were the overstuffed frat boys working down on Wall Street, the con artists in Times Square, the stealth fondler on the subway, the advertising men who started ruining the business I worked for. You signed my checks, I cashed them willingly.

The 2000s, you had some sort of TV show? I paid no attention. Reality TV? It depressed the hell out of me. You were the set-up preceding the punchline, and you were the punchline too. The huckster, the snake, the landlord who kicked me out after I complained to the city that I had no heat. You had the soul of a subprime mortgage lender. I moved to the country, saw less of you there.

The two thousand tens, totally forgot about you for a while. We have Obama, and he is such a sane and beautiful human. He pretty much means what he says. We start, possibly, being better people in some ways. But there are guns everywhere, and Twitter is destroying our brains. Still, we can do this, everyone, we can beat this back. We’re on a roll. And then a bad dream again one night in 2016: You are the Child Catcher again, the Greediest Man in the World, you’re now exposing my Barbie dolls’ plastic parts. To satisfy your monstrous ego, you run for President. My subconscious has lost its mind. I wake up and you’ve taken the election. The Greediest Man in the World made it to the top. Like a heart floating in formaldehyde, you are divorced from all compassion. Lonely, I feel lonely for the world. But we can turn this disaster around! We can change the outcome!

January 20, 2017: Inauguration Day comes and we haven’t changed the outcome. Not yet anyway. But there is still time, the credits have not rolled, and my daughter, who was never all that interested in Barbie Dolls, who never even saw Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, still has a look of hope on her face. She was reared on Barack and Michelle. She believes in a benevolent world. So watch out, mister president-elect, the children will be doing the catching soon enough.

 

tumblr_ld2hy9IPBB1qdumslo1_500_large

 

 

 

 

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

What Are the Odds of Donald Trump Serving All Four Years of His Term?

THE END OF THE ROAD IS NEAR. Assuming he is sworn in one week from now—and after this week’s revelation that he is, in fact, a compromised Russian intelligence asset, nothing but nothing would surprise me; today is Friday the 13th, after all—Donald J. Trump will be the oldest first-term president in our history.

His advanced age is one of many factors that make his successful completion of the four-year term unlikely. Below, I’ve provided the odds for various outcomes.

Les jeux sont faits. Please your bets, people. Remember, in gambling, the house always wins—unless the casino is owned by Donald J. Trump.

trump-casinos

He is impeached.
His conflicts of interests are so egregious that Congress has cause to impeach him the second he’s sworn in. All it will take is sufficient political cover for enough Republicans (21 in the House, 18 in the Senate) to feel safe enough to join the Democrats in dropping the gavel. If his dealings with Putin and the Russians are deeper than we think—spoiler alert: they are; they also reek of urine—Trump may well be gone sooner than William Henry Harrison, our ninth president, who lasted all of 32 days in office.
Odds: 3 to 1

He resigns (in disgrace).
If impeached, would he fight? Unlikely, especially if the charges against him are really terrible. He has a history of settling in court and then spinning the outcome. More likely, he’d resign before it got that far. If, for example, Putin leaks the video of Trump at the orgy in Moscow that allegedly exists (even if the “golden shower” one does not), even the shameless Donald J. Trump would have to step down, n’est-ce pas? This way he can salvage “Celebrity Apprentice” from Ah-nold.
Odds: 3 to 1

He dies of natural causes.
Whatever his personal physician may have suggested about his robust health, Donald Trump is a 70-year-old man, 30 pounds overweight, who sleeps less than four hours a night and subsists on fast food, and whose tangerine pallor is perhaps more indicative of liver dysfunction than tanning-bed mishap. After an exhausting 18-month campaign, he is now about to embark on what is the most stressful job there is. Would anyone be that surprised if he keeled over of Herod’s Evil at some point between now and 2020?
Odds: 10 to 1

He is assassinated.
First, math: four of our forty-five presidents have been shot dead, and (at least) four others survived serious assassination attempts (Jackson, both Roosevelts, Reagan). Second, history: demagogues like DJT are notorious for being murdered by betrayed former fanboys; his staunchest supporters are armed to the teeth and have well-documented anger issues and a propensity for violence. Oh, and he’s picked a fight with the CIA, an organization which SPECIALIZES IN KILLING PEOPLE. And, to top it off, his use of private security puts him more at risk. To state the obvious: assassination is a horrible outcome, and I don’t wish it on Trump, or anyone else. But if I were the PEE-OTUS, I’d stay away from theaters, railway stations, exposition pavilions, and Dallas.
Odds: 10 to 1

He is incapacitated and thus removed.
Maybe Trump is a congenital liar…or maybe he’s actually delusional and has had a psychotic break. His father has Alzheimer’s…does he? Perhaps he’ll have a massive stroke while watching SNL, depriving him of the ability to speak. The 25th Amendment was passed for a reason. Maybe we should take it for a spin.
Odds: 20 to 1

He serves the full four years of his term.
Half of Florida will be underwater by then, there will be a pipeline through my backyard, and Russia will have annexed two of the three Baltic States. But hey, Vive la Trump.
Odds: 20 to 1

Something else happens that prevents him from serving four years as president.
He declares martial law and becomes a full-on dictator, nuclear war with North Korea renders this little game moot, our alien overlords reveal themselves at last to humans other than Alex Jones, we focus really really hard on our I Ching sticks and wake up in an alternate reality in which Hillary is the president, etc.
Odds: 300 to 1

~

Caveats: I’m not endorsing any of these outcomes, just sizing up the odds. Also, I do not gamble, nor do I run a gaming facility. These are presented, like so many of Trump’s tweets, for entertainment purposes only.

Posted in Current Events | Tagged | 2 Comments

Cheer Up, Trump Haters: It’ll Get Worse!

President+Elect+Donald+Trump+Holds+Press+Conference+ch3fUHf-8h1x

WELL, THAT PRESS CONFERENCE was…something, huh? Predictably shambolic to the point of parody. Only more so. Satire and ridicule no longer register; we’re down the faux-golden rabbit hole, and it smells a lot like…urine. The unprecedented combination of incompetence and unscrupulousness on display makes George W. Bush look like Thomas Jefferson. What a national embarrassment. And if we’re counting on the media (many of whom laughed dutifully like dead-eyed show dogs at the appropriate moments, proving the only thing more astonishing than Trump’s truthless mendacity is the imperturbable fashion with which these bootlickers lap it up — for access, for ratings) to hold this buffoon in any way accountable, it’s going to be a long, brutal slog.

Special kudos to Jake Tapper, sitting afterward beside the emptiest suit in modern journalism, Wolf Blitzer, and making a play for his colleague’s crown: that immediate capitulation, equal parts petulant but unctuous, marks a new low in what may become a bottomless pit in the years (months? weeks? days? minutes?) ahead. Like a pathetic nerd willing to endure endless wedgies from the jocks for the pleasure of being in their company, these cowards are pleading with Trump to understand they aren’t the ones pushing “fake news” about a man who started the Obama “birther” conspiracy. For anyone struggling to understand why what Buzzfeed did is not only defensible, but imperative, it’s useful, as ever, to turn to our man George Orwell, who wrote: “Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations.” That precept, already in grave peril pre-Trump, is going to be tested to previously unimaginable limits in the years (months? weeks? days? minutes?) ahead.

Yet, in a surreal best case scenario for the GOP, even the most plugged-in fanatic can’t keep pace with the outrages and things-that-would-normally-qualify-as-headline-dominating-scandals (Exhibit A: that stunt, during the press conference—with the lawyer spewing falsehood after ruse after gambit to explain why, in fact, there are no conflicts of interest—normally would require, by the laws of irony, a lightning bolt to crash into the room, incinerating everyone present. Exhibit B: the mere fact that a wretched poltroon like Jeff Sessions is being mentioned, in 2017–outside a Top Ten list of most despicable public servants in American history–would usually oblige weeks of discussion and deliberation). We can’t even wrap our minds around the depravity of Trump’s alleged Russian adventures (when The Donald denied being down with water sports because he’s a germaphobe, and some of the press tittered, it was a particularly low point in yesterday’s spectacle), so these types of distractions will likely enable a host of unsavory cretins to coast through their confirmations unscathed, assuming their roles in Trump’s administration.

I’ll confess that after yesterday’s infomercial, I mean press conference, I had a fleeting (however naive) revelation: despite his bluster, once the polling became clear, Trump would not willingly take away health care from so many of the red state suckers. As more folks figured out what’s really going on, and we saw more stories like this, we could count on Trump, quite paradoxically and only because of his colossal ego, to be the unforeseen monkey wrench in Ryan & McConnell’s vision of undoing everything positive, post-FDR.

And yet, we wake up today to discover (once again), by having no shame whatsoever, the GOP is figuring out that in a nation increasingly populated by children, obfuscation without apology (or explanation) is the best way to advance an agenda and suffer minimal, if any blowback. In today’s America, our reality is that a black man giving millions of people health care is many times more politically damaging than a rich white man taking it away from them. Until, that is, they figure out exactly what they had, what’s gone, and the person they voted for did what they thought they wanted

And then, some accountability, at long last? Not necessarily.

Guess what? It can get even worse.

Just after the election results came in, I realized most of what passes for Republican intelligentsia were so many dogs that inexplicably caught the car. Demonizing Obamacare by any means necessary was easy as it was effective, because it didn’t require any action, aside from reciting boilerplate propaganda and whipping useful idiots into the type of frenzy that could make a President Donald Trump possible. But, even the most cynical of these charlatans had to know, once it got down to the nuts and bolts of fucking over tens of millions of citizens, it might prove…complicated. My prediction, cynical in its own right, turns out to have been optimistic (!): I proposed that, if they were smart, Trump & Co. would immediately “repeal” Obamacare, replace it with the exact same thing (never forget, the ACA is a compromise crafted in conservative think tanks), call it Trumpcare, and convert the most spectacular sleight of hand in political history.

But I overlooked one important thing: the current crop of Republicans don’t give the slightest shit about people, or their health care, and we now have the votes to prove it.

It occurs to me that doing this maneuver (in the dead of night, natch), effectively forcing repeal (damn the torpedoes, declare victory, mission accomplished, etc.) without a net — or the pesky collective conscience to fret about how it will play in the media, much less actual peoples’ lives — proves that luck, combined with a brazen will to power for power’s sake, provides (another) miraculous opportunity. If, in fact, today signals the beginning of the end of Obamacare, effective immediately, people will steadily figure out what’s going on (way too late, as always) and they will, of course, be apoplectic. Someone will have to answer for that rage, and it won’t be Paul Ryan or Mitch McConnell. In a perfect storm so repellent it causes one to ponder the actuality of the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea, they’ll use Trump as ballast, impeach him, and tie the repeal of Obamacare to…Trump. And it will work, because enough Republicans (and all Democrats) will relish the idea of jettisoning Mr. Make America Great Again from the Oval Office. A win/win for all involved, right?

Wrong. The unfathomable good fortune bestowed on Pence (and Ryan and Big Mac) will reach wet dream proportions: with Trump gone (and presumably having the stench of failure providing cover) a unified GOP will finally have unfettered access to dismantling anything and everything these sadists deem “progressive”. Worse, they’ll likely have years of accountability-free momentum, because between blaming Obama (duh) and Trump (who, of course, they all hate anyway), they’ll somehow position themselves as the ones who got rid of Obama and saved us all from Trump.

103804705-GettyImages-577719308.1910x1000

Trump is sufficiently unconscionable he tends to camouflage the horrifying prospect of Pence as the ultimate GOP fantasy: a perfect amalgamation of Reagan, Newt Gingrich and Jerry Falwell, where mendacity meets opportunism, all gussied up in an aw shucks, superficial piety. He will, without the least reservation, blank-check the most ruthless Ayn Rand fetishists in history, making the Bush/Cheney years seem like a utopia of regulation and civil rights and market stability.

The typically gullible and feckless Democrats will think—abetted of course by an ever-pliant media—that since Pence is calm, soft-spoken and smiles a lot, they can reason with him. And with a shit-eating smirk, he’ll shut them down on every single issue, including ones (privatizing Social Security) that Trump, possibly, would have blanched at. And for every policy that undoes equality or the hope of middle-class advancement (The working poor? Face, meet Boot), credulous sycophants like Chuck Todd will allow weasels like Paul Ryan to frown meaningfully and talk about how none of this is easy, but governing requires difficult decisions and God Bless America.

And best case scenario, in four-to-eight years there’ll be a Bud Lite type of reckoning (the Democrats emboldened enough to campaign on positions that were middle of the road a decade ago), and the GOP (and their enablers in the business community and media—assuming the two entities are distinguishable by this point) will start whining, again, about the debt being amassed to pull us out of the mess, the one no one could have seen coming. That is, unless the hole is not finally too deep, a fantasy that causes so many of our right-leaning members of Congress to arise with Sildenafil-assisted morning wood every day.

Cheer up, things can get worse. Much worse. Impeaching Trump, that big, bloated white whale, may not be the prize we’re after. Indeed, there’s a possibility that keeping him in office may be the only thing preventing the half-ass Ahabs behind him from partying like it’s 1929.

 

 

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Home States

 

Pennsylvania

Your state falls late that evening. This particular battleground has tipped the political war. The postmortem points to the county of York, where you grew up, as one of three nationwide that decided the presidential election. Old high school classmates rejoice/seethe over the whole keystone turning GOP red. You have no relevant response to their social media posts besides suddenly feeling unwelcome to participate. Because you left the county, the state, and the borders of your nation years ago. You live in a foreign time-zone, half a day away. Your absentee vote wasn’t enough to prevent the worst-case scenario. You should have seen the self-actualized death wish coming. Your sense of no longer belonging flickers along with the implausible idea of the United States of America that you’ve always defended to skeptics abroad. You wonder if you can still convince even yourself. You wonder if you can ever return. You retrace your steps in search of homes lost.

 

Ohio

Layoffs at the steel plant hit the town of Lorain when you were in elementary school. You can’t play Atari at your friend’s house because his Dad watches t.v. in the den now during the day. You skip to collecting bottle caps of Sunkist and Genesee in the park that ends at Lake Erie. Someday in the future you’ll swim to Canada or dig to China, whichever might make you famous enough to be featured on PM Magazine. These plans stay with you, as the sun drops below the sycamores and you run home as fast as possible without the bottle caps spilling out of your pockets onto the uneven sidewalk.

 

Indiana

Your eyes follow the dipping lines of the telephone poles along the train tracks. Your grandmother is bringing you for a visit to a temporary parsonage in Fort Wayne. Your grandfather serves as an interim pastor there for a small congregation at a Brethren church. On Sunday morning, you mumble to the beaming old women and their husbands with ramrod posture during the “passing of the peace to your neighbors.” Your grandfather delivers a sermon about forgiveness and then asks the people in the pews to stand again for a hymn. The warbling voices together declare that grace has brought us safe thus far.

 

Confusion

Eazy-E rhymes about his Tec-9. It sounds more brutal because you’re in the passenger seat of a Mercedes Benz S-Class that your teammate received for his 16th birthday. You both stink from tennis practice as he drives and chugs Snapple, tossing the empty bottles into his backseat. You are probably both guilty of something. You consider making a joke about his uncle, the congressman from your district, currently in the news for overdrafting his House checking account. Instead your teammate talks over the gangsta rap to impart a vague lesson from the book that’s become his newest obsession: The Art of the Deal, by a real-estate tycoon.

 

Emergency

You and your beautiful, hilarious family of college friends are free to entertain notions about the end of the rest of the world. You sing along with an REM song about it. You critique impending-disaster blockbusters and jarring indie films on societal decay. Meanwhile, the job market is the best the country has ever seen. But when your roommate turns to you the night before graduation and asks “So how does it feel to be living at the collapse of western civilization?” it becomes the most meaningful question about the passing utopia you’ve just realized.

 

Hollywood

You and your date attend prom at an East L.A. high school closed on a Tuesday in September. The wardrobe department has provided your tuxedo and your assigned date’s blue dress. All the extras have been warned not to actually drink the liquid in the punchbowl. Someone jokes about spiking it anyway. You’re all feeling giddy and eighteen years old. Through the multiple takes, you and your date pull off a twirl you conspired over to stand out when you watch, separately and onto other so-called fulfilling jobs, on the big screen. You both believe you’ve stolen the show. You will tell this story more often than that of your own high school prom as the moment gradually replaces your real, stilted senior dance under the low lights of your nostalgia.

 

Silicon Valley

You exchange instant messenger chats with a French woman in the cubicle beside you. She’s on the same dial-in conference call with your client whose dotcom company has almost nailed their narrative. The marketing executive reiterates that the Internet will take care of everything. Your focus remains on the tiny corner chat window of your desktop. What are you doing after this maybe we could drive to Half Moon Bay? You clatter at her and then hit enter. The cursor blinks silent on the reply. From the call in your ear, the executive affirms that they’ll be rounding up the unique visitor numbers in the press release. Half Moon Bay sounds like a magic California place that does not exist, your otherworldly coworker messages back. Once you finally get there, your resolve to show her otherwise will be enough to tempt the magical part.

 

Texas

You visit her French family and home in Burgundy. Your future father-in-law inquires if George W. Bush is hiding his real cunning and intelligence while publicly pretending to be a stupid cowboy. Your bet is on authentic stupidity. The fries in America have become freedom now because the French wanted no part of the war. In France, zero thoughts turn to frites. You stress that most Texans aren’t cowboys and likewise are not that stupid, as a posture or otherwise. “Same for most Americans,” you add in a way that rings all the more defensive and desperate in the dining room with his daughter, who is five months pregnant with your child.

 

Virginia

With your wife and two toddler-aged girls, you camp for the first night of a summer cross-country trip in Shenandoah National Park. White-tailed deer prance through your campsite in regular intervals. Your younger daughter chases them through the open woods. You deem the creatures an omen of a safe trip. You offer the benefit of doubt and a hello to a fellow camper with Confederate flag bumper stickers. You later visit sites dedicated to the story of Pocahontas, as your dynamo travel companions try to match the placards you read aloud with the Disney movie and the Colors of the Wind. You proceed on the wide-eyed belief that this is the new world.

 

img_7273

 

New York

It’s December and your daughters have grown twice as old in a blink. The Central Park ice skating rink is decorated and buzzing from the crowded cosmopolitan amalgam of visitors there to celebrate the season. The foreign language your daughters speak swirls together with the many others. The only outside influence that feels incongruous is a trademark stamped along the rink wall and on the cups of hot chocolate: Trump. You justify the money given by telling yourself that the brand is a dreary relic, long ago eclipsed by more advanced surroundings.

 

Kentucky

Your family continues to cross borders and languages because you still can. The Middle Eastern nation of Oman is demure and tranquil. Leaving the capital Muscat, everyone needs lunch before the open road along the Gulf and into the desert. You spot a KFC. The unmistakable image of Colonel Sanders smiles above the letters in Arabic. You eat there with extra helpings of irony and shame. At breakfast the next day, the hostess at your idyllic accommodation provides the opposite culinary experience, slow meals of astonishing fresh food shared with careful, glowing hospitality. Her fascinated questions about America don’t include the fact that, as you’ll later learn, US Secretary of State Kerry is also in the country meeting with Iranian officials, arranged by Oman’s sultan, to negotiate a nuclear arms agreement.

 

Colorado

The Rocky Mountain green is deeper than the Appalachian. You’re on a hiking trail called the 4th of July. The Front Range trees and the wildflowers look too pristine to be real. You’ve reconvened with two old grade school friends. The dynamic among you has waited patiently after decades to resurface unchanged for this visit. You come down the mountains and drink while watching the last night of the GOP convention. At the first glimpse of the nominee, his silhouette appears to be levitated by the blinding stage lights. When he emerges to speak, he sounds sated, malicious, and lost. But your mind is still on the trail and you dismiss anything you’re viewing on a screen. From where you stood earlier that day, you were sure you could see the line of the continental divide.

 

Sports

A stranger visiting from Boston sits next to you at an ex-pat bar near the Place St. Michel in Paris. You watch separate, adjacent screens of American pro football, his loyalty to New England, yours to Cleveland since your days with bottle caps by Lake Erie. The Patriots are winning as usual. The Browns, as per eternity, are losing. During commercial breaks, the Boston man guesses that you are a Hillary Clinton supporter. The way he says so indicates he isn’t. He switches to the subject of the email investigation which the FBI director just reopened. He relates a story of his brother who works at a golf course near Quantico. James Comey had played a round a few weeks prior and someone in his entourage left a bag behind. When it was recovered, his brother looked inside to find it containing, not golf clubs, but several automatic weapons. When the brother returned it, the director invited him as a thank-you to an afternoon at the Bureau shooting range. The anecdote sounds true, you think, and Comey sounds like an idiot. But it’s not newsworthy enough to be fact-checked into falsehood. You sit on implications while the Cleveland Browns throw another interception.

 

Grace

The day after the 2016 presidential election, a viral video shows students at a school a mile from your old house in York, Pennsylvania. They hold Trump signs and chant “White power!” in the hallways. The country isn’t prepared for the further loss to come. You doubt most Americans can afford undivided attention. You doubt that your own far-flung words will make a difference. They will never rhyme or shock or flatter or move like a virus. You will continue to be a misfit introvert not from around anywhere. You will never stitch together the illusory connections of your native country and its various states of mind. It may never add up. But you will write despite the noise. And you will belong despite the doubt. You are still American enough to trust that the stories you tell yourself—an individual reaching toward the second-person whole, a state reaching toward an amazing, imperfect union—will lead you home.

 

Iowa

Among the cornfields of your distant relative’s farm, you rode on the back of a Massey Ferguson tractor, the largest machine you ever thought possible in the wide world. Here is the churned soil where many of those who share your last name are now buried. It’s a place you can picture yourself emigrating to at the next honest call for unity. It’s where the heartland might have more porous borders. It’s where the cycle begins again.

 

 

Posted in Memoir | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Unbearable Hopelessness of Trump (and Being)

I am hopeful that this essay will be the first of two.

That is about all I am hopeful about.

I know you’re already despairing, and I have nothing to offer to talk you out of it. Like you, I have clicked the links that promise perspective or wisdom from people I respect or steps I can take to make a difference in this Time of Great Bullshit.

But I am not hopeful about them. Civil liberties, a free, non-libelous press, a government that wins some other way than cheating and disenfranchising its citizenry, equal rights, access to that which should be guaranteed me as a human, these are not things I or anyone should have to pay for. So donating to organizations which support what by rights ought already belong to all of us does not ease my despair. Nor does the advice to call my representatives. The very fact that it seems reasonable to so many of us that I should call my actual elected representative and say, “I wanted to let you know that I oppose putting a white supremacist in the White House and urge you to do the same,” is proof enough of the end of days.

We are fucked, but that’s not why I’m despairing. I’m despairing because I can’t see how we won’t always be fucked. Take Anthony Weiner (please). Anthony Weiner is a Democrat, and you probably agree with 99 percent of his political positions, but you wouldn’t vote for him anyway because he sends pictures of his penis to teenagers. Good for you. Unfortunately, it’s why you’re fucked. You see lying, cheating, unscrupulous behavior, and illegal activities as criminal, reprehensible, dishonest, and unfair. If your candidate, say, redrew the borders of the district to ensure reelection, you wouldn’t vote for him. (I am wearing the male pronoun for elected officials now as a hair shirt.) If your candidate bragged about being smart enough not to pay taxes, you wouldn’t vote for him. If your candidate intimidated the people who were least likely to vote for him, you wouldn’t vote for him either. If your candidate came out and said — proudly said — hateful things about women and people of color and LGBT people and Muslim people and immigrant people and minority people and disabled people and really any people, you wouldn’t vote for him.

Which is too bad for you because their candidate wins both in spite of those things and because of those things. Some on their side, unlike you, are content to shrug and admit that their candidate does and says objectionable things, but they’re voting for him anyway because they want what he promises. Some, in contrast, see it as a sign of strength that their candidate lies, cheats, steals, and is as loud an asshole as possible. They agree that it’s smart rather than reprehensible that he doesn’t pay his taxes. They are delighted that when their candidate couldn’t win the regular way, he was strong enough to get the boundaries redrawn so he could. They agree that certain categories of people are and should be less than and are happy not only that someone’s finally saying so but that he’s making it okay for everyone else to say so as well. It’s actually hard for me to decide which of these positions is more deplorable.

The upshot is that your candidate has to find a way to win without cheating while their candidate thrives by doing so. This is just as well because once in office, your candidate has to play by the rules whereas theirs flouts them with impunity. Same reason. Your side didn’t like fifty percent of the current sitting members of the Supreme Court, and for good reason, but they advised and consented anyway because that’s their job as laid out by the Constitution. If they had simply crossed their arms and said, like five-year-olds, “Nope, we won’t and you can’t make us,” their side would have screamed bloody murder, and you would begrudgingly admit that your representatives weren’t doing their jobs. Whereas their side said exactly that — and promised to continue to do exactly that for years and decades until they got their way — and they’re getting away with it.

If you have any doubt that your side will confirm whatever piece of shit their side puts up, I have bad news about your side.

All this means more than that we lost. It means we will continue to. Their side is playing a long game. And they’re getting away with it, in part because, again, if your media of choice made shit up and reported it as truth, you’d stop reading/listening/engaging with it. Their media reports all sorts of made up, hateful bullshit about our side, and their side either doesn’t mind or doesn’t notice. Either way, we’re fucked.

Because I am a writer and because so many of my friends are writers, what’s been circulating in my circles are these familiar hopes: Love trumps hate. We need writers now more than ever. We must tell our stories and others’ stories. We must read and listen and empathize and teach. That is how we prevail.

Up until November 8, I believed all that. Not just believed it, built my whole world, my whole worldview, around it. I don’t want to be writing this essay. But I don’t know if I believe it anymore.

I think about those electoral maps, the ones that show what the country would look like if only men voted or only people under 25 voted or only college graduates voted, and wonder what they would look like if they showed how only the people who read at least one whole book last year voted. We’re writing — we’re writing like mad — but we’re writing for the choir. The point of reading books is to understand what it’s like to be and feel and empathize with and as someone you’re not. The people who are willing to do that are on your side already. The people who aren’t aren’t and aren’t interested.

The moral of the story — the moral of all stories, the point of narrative — is always that love prevails, that understanding and appreciating difference makes us stronger, that those who’ve been treated cruelly have those wrongs righted, that those who win do so because they learn and grow. The moral of the story is also always that those who lie, cheat, steal, ruin, hate, wallow, and swindle will lose. In stories, they always lose.

In life, they win. They win because they get to play by different rules.

My hopes, my scant hopes, are these:

  1. Even despite the cheating and manipulating and lying and different rules, it’s still close. Our side is hanging in with a deck stacked like bricks against them.
  2. Narrative is long. So perhaps it will prevail eventually. Perhaps I am despairing prematurely.
  3. We used to burn people alive in the town square or behead them for public gratification and then display those heads, also for public gratification. At least we don’t do that in this country anymore.
  4. Maybe in a few months, I’ll write a second essay humbly taking back some of what I’ve written here.

It’s possible though that when the only real hope I can come up with is, “At least we don’t set people on fire anymore,” I haven’t come up with any hope at all.

hopelessness

 

Posted in Politics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Trump’s Cabinet Picks are Contestants on New Season of The Apprentice

SINCE ELECTION DAY, Donald Trump has trolled Democrats, and many moderate Republicans, by assembling what is, by any objective measure, the least qualified Cabinet in the history of the Republic.

His chief strategist traffics in anti-Semitism, and his national security adviser in conspiracy theories. His attorney general was too racist for the Reagan Administration. His secretary of education and his EPA chair want to destroy the agencies they will now head. His Treasury pick comes from Goldman Sachs, another target of his anti-Hillary campaign scorn. The only experience Ben Carson, his choice for HUD, has with housing is that he physically lives in a house. He’s tapped the head of a fake wrestling federation to helm the SBA; as one of precious few women in a room full of sexual predators and domestic abusers, she may well have to put her fake wrestling knowledge to actual use. Energy pick Rick Perry, fresh off his disastrous run on Dancing with the Stars, wanted to eliminate the department he will now head but could not remember it.

This isn’t just a lousy cabinet. This is egregiously awful. This is like The Producers, where he’s actively trying to make it suck. It’s almost like Trump’s attempted to take the worst possible people and elevate them to the plum positions. Like, Sarah Palin, a human being I would not trust to work the lunch shift at McDonald’s, is in charge of the VA; what message does that send to our armed forces?

The question is, what’s the play here? Is Trump so insecure that he needs to surround himself with losers, so he looks marginally better by comparison?

Then came news that Trump will continue to produce “The Apprentice” while he’s the president, and it all makes sense. Installing Perry at Energy, or Carson at HUD, is no different than hiring Meat Loaf or Gary Busey for a job for which they possess no qualifications beyond name recognition.

For the next few years, when each of these Cabinet fuck-ups fucks something up, we’ll be treated to the White House edition of Trump’s signature program, when he calls Mike Flynn or Jeff Sessions into the Oval Office to say: “You’re fired!” And when this happens, we will love it!

The campaign was run like a reality show. His Administration will be the same.

The difference, of course, is that it doesn’t matter if Omarosa makes a poor decision about Trump Vodka. Who cares? But I’m not sure I want a guy who believes Hillary Clinton is a child sex trafficker to whisper in Trump’s ear about how to handle North Korea. Because “you’re fired” is something Short Fingers could also say to a nuclear missile.

Can't spell APPRENTICE without P-E-N-C-E

Can’t spell APPRENTICE without P-E-N-C-E

Posted in Current Events | Tagged , | 1 Comment

How Hamilton Lost Us The Election

Here’s what I think lost us this election: Hamilton.

I like musical theater. My dad took me to see Hello, Dolly when I was five, and I was hooked. I am often listening obsessively to musicals. What’s weird is not that I’ve been listening to Hamilton nonstop all year. What’s weird is that so many of the rest of you have been. It’s unusual for me to be hitting the zeitgeist, whatever it is. But not as unusual as it is for whatever it is to be a Broadway musical. Until November, I thought this was great news. Now I think it’s ruined everything in the world forever.

Here’s what we learn from Hamilton:

  • Individual people can rise up and defeat their corrupt government.
  • They do this by reading widely, writing well, and being educated.
  • Poor people can win power from wealthy people by being smart, talented, and hard working.
  • Immigrants are worthwhile humans.
  • People of color are worthwhile humans.
  • Women are worthwhile humans. The stronger and more outspoken they are, the more worthwhile. And sexy.
  • In the face of adversity, diverse people come together, stand together, and in so doing, triumph.
  • It is possible to fight the entrenched power structures, the ancestral wealth, the unfair systems, the oppressors who inherited their privileges. And win.
  • Intelligent, invested government leaders can have reasonable disagreements about complex things and work hard to come to smart compromises.
  • History will remember your actions and your inactions. Saying despicable things, engaging in despicable behavior will disqualify you going forward because history does not forget.
  • Craven candidates who insolently stoke and stroke the masses just to get elected won’t.
  • Politicians become unelectable when citizens find out they engage in tawdry, inappropriate sexual behavior.
  • What you say and what you write and what you stand for matters.
  • Shooting people is stupid.

And never mind the morals of the story, from the very fact of Hamilton’s unprecedented popularity we learn:

  • Storytelling makes the world a better place.
  • Art makes the world a better place.
  • Diversity is good.
  • Art inspires people, lots of people, different people, people as varied as snooty theater critics and rap aficionados, people as varied as the celebrities who are finagling orchestra seats to this thing despite it’s being sold out until forever and my eight-year-old.
  • Art education pays off in spades.
  • Eight-hundred-plus page biographies of lesser known founding fathers are cool.
  • Hip hop is important.
  • High art and culture isn’t just for snobs.
  • In fact, high art and culture isn’t what you think it is.
  • There is power in community, in sitting together in a dark room with a bunch of strangers and having a shared experience and being changed.

We, the Hamilton-obsessed, learned all that. Most of us probably believed it anyway, but once you listen to the cast recording a few hundred times, it gets into your bones. You can no longer not believe it. It’s one of the best things about musicals actually. It’s hard to be cynical in the face of them. A chorus line, a tap number, actors in flight harnesses, lovers singing in each other’s faces — you just can’t be ironic or pessimistic or too-cool-for-school when you watch stuff like this. If you fail to believe, Tinkerbell dies.

But that hope, that optimism, that faith and belief, that certainty that good and right win, that fairness matters, that love trumps hate, all of that made us sure there was no way this election could go badly. All of that made us confident that Hillary would win. Of course she would. Of course the American electorate had love and justice in its heart, and love and justice could vote no other way.

Did we lose because we were so confident we couldn’t? I don’t know. But I do know that when we lost, we lost so much. We lost the White House. We lost our government. But we also lost our narrative. We lost our faith. We lost our optimism and our trust in the goodness of our fellow citizens. And we were stunned — I remain, in fact, gobsmacked and despairing — because, Hamilton-taught, there was no way this could happen. But it did.

I’m not sure I believe it, but I do hope our hope lies in Hamilton too.

Rise up.

There will be a revolution. We’re going to have to do it together. What form that will take, what it will mean, remains to be seen. But for starters…

We write our way out of hell.

Those of us who write have to write. We were writing in October too, and look how well that worked, so we have to write different, more, louder. We have to tell our stories. We have to tell other people’s stories as well.

We write like we’re running out of time.

And we have to do it quickly. Urgently. Frequently. And in large volume.

We pass the plate around, move total strangers to kindness with our stories.

We give money to individuals who need it, to organizations who help individuals who need it, to organizations who protect our rights, our liberties, our press, our environment, our culture, our world. This is one quantifiable way writing, storytelling, helps. We give. And we inspire other people to give.

Wait for it, wait for it.

History is long. And slow. This is a dark moment which we must use to lead to lighter days. Progress is hard to see while it’s happening. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t happening.

This is the eye of the hurricane.

He’s been declared the winner but not yet ascended to office. He’s appointed the cronies, but they’ve yet to take their seats. He’s blustered and insulted and abused, but does he dare? We don’t know yet, so we take this grace period, these last blessed days of the previous blessed administration to regroup, repair, rebuild our faith. And get ready for what’s coming. After all, history has its eye on us.

 

Hamilton-burr Duel, 1804 Painting; Hamilton-burr Duel, 1804 Art Print for sale

Hamilton-Burr duel, 1804

 

Posted in Popular Culture | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment